“What’s going on here?” I called out, and Vanderbilt turned to stare at me, his face pale in the light of the two naked bulbs hanging from the hallway ceiling. His mouth opened, but no sound came out, and he pressed a fist against it as if he might be sick.

He turned away again, doubling over and retching. And then I saw the bright shape under the silvery moonlight, motionless on the damp gray cobblestones.

My footsteps slowed. The night enveloped me like a giant clammy fist. A cacophony of champagne pops, happy shouts, and jazz rose up to meet midnight in the crowded streets all around us, but here in this sheltered courtyard, no one acknowledged the time. The air smelled sharply of vomit, thanks to Vanderbilt, and something else underneath it I couldn’t place and didn’t want to name.

I knew this courtyard at night. It was the place where rats skittered when I dumped the mop water or took out trash to the burn barrel. It was the place I trudged through to get home after closing, when my feet were tired and my eyes barely open. The place we were supposed to escape through if Prohibition agents or cops came through the front.

Beyond the slanted rectangle of yellow light from the open door, just past the dark shadow of the balcony above, Fitzroy and Rockefeller crouched over the shape on the ground, two black hulks in their dark suits. Rockefeller was touching the shape gently and murmuring something.

It was a person. A body.

“Who . . . ?” I said, my voice catching in my throat, coming out small.

No one heard me except Frank, who touched my arm as if to stop me moving forward, stop me getting involved, make me let him go first. None of which I was going to do.

“Who is she?” I said, louder. The body, it was obvious now that my eyes were adjusting to the dark, was a woman’s. A girl’s. Her beaded gold dress and brilliant hair spread out across the cobblestones beside the dry fountain like a shining puddle. A beaded handbag lay a few feet away.

No one answered me. I looked to my right at the two girls, clinging to each other and crying, both studiously not looking at the body.

I didn’t want to look either. At least I didn’t think I wanted to look, knew Ishouldn’t want to look, but my eyes were drawn back to it. My feet carried me closer.

Rockefeller picked up her hand, white and luminous in a ray of moonlight, and felt for a pulse in her wrist.

“Is she . . . all right?” I said, feeling a fool even as I said it. There was no way she was all right.

“She’s dead!” wailed one of the girls. “Her eyes! Just look at her eyes!”

They were open, staring upward as if into the shadowed face of the dark-­haired boy hovering over her. Her head lay at a strange angle against the foot of the fountain. A fine mist beaded and glistened on her pale brow, her beautifully rounded cheekbones, her pink lips, her bright hair.

It was Arimentha. The girl who’d known Marion. The girl who’d wronged him terribly once, somehow, by her own admission.

But whatever she’d done, she hadn’t deserved this. To die here on the cold ground, her body left to grow damp with mist and mop water while seventeen versions of “Auld Lang Syne”played around her and the whole Quarter celebrated.

No one deserved this.

My eyes pricked with tears I wasn’t expecting. Why should I cry for this girl? Why should I feel bile in the back of my own throat at the sight of her blank eyes, her wasted life? “Do you know what happened to her?” Frank asked, looking around at the rich kids. “Did you see anything?”

They shook their heads, their eyes wide and staring.

“I think . . .” Rockefeller spoke up, his voice choked. “I think she fell off the balcony.”

“Or someone pushed her,” one of the girls whimpered, the brunette who until recently had been screaming continuously.

“What was she doing up there?” the other girl said. She was almost my height with auburn hair, though everything was washed strange and blue in the moonlight. “Look there in her hand—­what’s that?”

A folded paper lay in Arimentha’s softly curled hand. In two strides, I’d reached her and plucked the paper up into my own hand.

“You shouldn’t do that,” Rockefeller said, straightening out of his crouch. “The police will want the crime scene to stay as it is.”

“If it’s a crime at all,” I said. “Like you said, she could’vefallen.”

Whether this was a murder or an accident, it had happened at Aunt Cal’s club—­my club tonight—­and I would decide what we did about it.

I held the paper up to the moonlight and saw it was a playbill for a circus that had already left town the week before. We had a stack of them still sitting on the end of the bar.

“What is it?” Fitzroy said, standing, too.

I ignored him and unfolded the paper. There was writing inside, a brief penciled letter, in a hand that looked like it would’ve been pretty if it wasn’t scrawled in such a hurry. I didn’t have the light or patience to interpret all the words, but I didn’t have to.

The letter began with “Dear Marion.”